How The X-Ray Shaped Modern Medicine and The Genetic Effects of Radiation.

ABSTRACT

The X-ray is known as one of the most profound scientific discoveries, especially in the Physics community. In medicine, they are regarded as one of the turning points to the modern practices that are used today. Yet, the dangers of these rays were found only after the initial discovery. There are three key features of the X-ray and its legacy; The man who discovered these rays, Wilhelm Röntgen, the impact their discovery and development had on the world, and the main side effect of the X-ray, Radiation. 

Key Words: X-ray, 1890’s, medicine, radiation. 

Annotated bibliography Report

Wilhelm Röntgen

  1. **Rontgen, W. C. (1896, April). THE NEW MARVEL IN PHOTOGRAPHY. [Interview transcript]. Gutenburg. Retrieved January 11, 2005, https://www.gutenberg.org/files/14663/14663-h/14663-h.htm#page403

Above is a link to an interview with Rontgen himself along with multiple articles on the X-ray and its effects. This is a primary source from 1896, a year after Rontgen’s discovery and it describes the X-rays, how he experimented with them and who he was as a man. This article(s) shows an array of images from some of the first X-rays produced and Rontgen himself as well as his University, where he held most of his lectures and experiments. 

There is also a section (taking place after the interview) about the significance of the X-rays around the globe, specifically in America, where Thomas Edison conducted his very own research on the profound Rontgen Rays. “The New Marvel In Photography” describes not only the importance of the X-ray, yet also the sensational light in which Rontgen and his Rays were shed. The X-ray was rapidly adopted by doctors and physicists and it almost immediately spread through the press and through the country of Germany. 

Rontgen is described by H.J.W. Dam (the interviewer) as a *“tall, slender and loosed-limbed man, whose appearance bespeaks enthusiasm and energy”(p. 11) He then proceeds to notice the extreme modesty of Professor Wilhelm Rontgen as the continuing compliments of his fame and his discovery were “laughed at” as he was *“too deeply interested in science to waste any time in thinking about himself”(p. 12) This leads J.W. to ask specifically about Rontgen’s research and how he discovered the “Unknown Rays” that would make history.

As J.W. is led to a large tin box and asked to “‘step inside”’, he wonders if his *“skeleton was to be photographed for general inspection, or [his] secret thoughts held up to light on a glass plate”(p. 13) Then W. Dam becomes a personal witness to the glory of the Rontgen Rays. He states in the ‘article-like’ part of his interview: “Through the metal plate, the paper, myself and the tin box, the invisible rays were flying, with an effect strange, interesting and uncanny.” J.W. reached the expected exclamation that “the light was rich and full, as if nothing lay between the paper and the tube”(p. 13) This initial surprise is common, for light is typically blocked by most objects, so how are the Rontgen Rays passing through solid, opaque objects in an entirely dark box?

In 1896, this answer did not exist within the human net of knowledge. Any object that did not obtain lead or platinum, or that was not a dense material such as bone or teeth was ignored practically entirely by the rays(or so it was thought). These “flimsy” objects did not absorb the X-ray, so it simply passed through these objects. Rontgen himself only knew of how to produce and visualize the X-ray, he admits he does not know what this ray is: *“‘is it light?’ (questions H.J.W. Dam.) ‘No’ ‘is it electricity?’ ‘Not in any known form’. ‘What is it?’ ‘I don’t know’” and right then and there “the discoverer of the X-ray thus stated as calmly his ignorance of their essence as has everybody else who has written on the phenomena thus far.”(p. 16) 

  1. Seliger, H. H. (1995, November). Wilhelm Conrad Rontgen and The Glimmer of light. http://xray.rutgers.edu/grad/612/seliger_nov95.pdf
  2. How Does an X-Ray Work? (n.d.). Wonderopolis, (102). https://wonderopolis.org/ wonder/how-does-an-x-ray-work (this source was used as a simple reference to how all the information discussed below came together)

This source(1995) is a research article written by Howard Harold Seliger, a professor in biology known for his study of bioluminescence. His paper describes the first events leading past and through the discovery on November 8th, 1895 and further into the X-rays effects on medicine and How The X-Ray Works. The Article holds photos of Mrs. Rontgen’s hand under the scope of the X-ray and further photos of the very lab Wilhelm Rontgen worked in.

Rontgen first discovered the X-ray by accident. He was experimenting with electromagnetic radiation and energy in a vacuum known as a cathode tube. In 1876 a physicist by the name of William Crookes was studying cathode rays, which were the inspiration and key foundation to Roentgen’s research and experiments. Rontgen’s discovery was apparently accidental in nature; he had not been attempting to revolutionize medicine in the process of these endeavors. He had only been looking to prove that “invisible high-frequency rays”,  post-Hermann von Helmholtz’s research, did indeed, exist. On Friday evening, November 8th, 1895 “a faint glimmer of light from a fluorescent screen caught Rontgen’s eye”(p. 1)

The tube in which this experiment was conducted, was surrounded in a “heavy cardboard” yet the fluorescent light was unaffected by this obstacle, and instead shone brightly through what was once thought would shield such penetration. He placed many objects in front of the fluorescent screen which held the ray, none seemed to bother this persistent light. Then, on that very evening, Rontgen placed his own hand between the cathode tube and the fluorescent screen. His dense bones obstructed the ‘new ray’ by absorbing the radiation, preventing the light to shine through on the other side of his hand. The result of this was a clear depiction of his detailed bone structure, still safely beneath his skin, which did not affect the rays. 

This effect can be resembled in a childish analogy; using a flashlight to make shadow puppets with one’s hands is done by blocking the flash light to project on the wall whatever shapes are so desired. With the X-ray, the terms are a tad restrained, in that this ‘shadow puppet’ can only be seen under more complicated conditions. The calcium in Rontgen’s bones absorb these rays which project a shadow onto the  screen behind his hand. He immediately realized this importance and how it could benefit the medical community. He continued the experiment that evening, getting second and third opinions the following days and becoming the ‘local gossip’ on a large scale in the science community in Germany at the time, his discovery eventually reaching other countries and nations. The Rontgen ray became a ‘popular science’, the public’s apparent interest spurred the growth of his discovery and Wilhelm Rontgen eventually received a Nobel Prize in 1901 for his contributions to medicine.

  1. Chodos, A., & Ouellette, J. (2001, November). Roentgen’s discovery of x-rays. APS News, Volume 10. https://www.aps.org/publications/apsnews/200111/history.cfm

This article discusses the immediacy of Rontgen’s discovery. The invention of the X-ray machine crowded the population and hospitals within just a year of the first publication of its existence. Scientific discoveries typically take a couple years, maybe decades to truly ‘catch on’ and be involved in society. Sometimes certain discoveries have yet to be put to use and are either studied instead of practiced or disregarded as books and papers, old history, gathering dust on a shelf. This is because most discoveries involving mankind need a solid gestation period. For example, The idea that Man could step foot on the moon in 1969 was incredible, an achievement shaping all days coming after that very first step. Men and Women today study and research extensively to further advance space travel. Rockets and space crafts are nowhere near public use, although one day, they might be a common form of public transport. 

So why was the X-ray adopted by the public so quickly? How did this immediately affect medicine? Why was this “invention” recognized by the public quicker than past inventions such as the light bulb or the stethoscope? Well the X-ray is not an invention. It is not the engineering of a rocket to place Man on the moon, nor is it the production of electricity as a circuit to produce light, and it is not the funnel design of a new medical tool to better hear a patient’s heartbeat. The X-ray has existed, Rontgen simply brought it to life. It was easy to use and reproduce the X-ray effect, it seemed to require no speculation, no further study and no improvement of the design. 

Immediate reactions of the public include the advertisements of “Bone portraits” and the written works of poems and books describing the wonderment of the X-ray. Common folk were utterly struck by the morbid detail of the human skeleton in such clear, real, living detail. Apparently the “first clinical use was in the US, Dartmouth, [Massachusetts] , when Edwin Brant Frost produced a plate of a patient’s Colles fracture for his brother, a local doctor. Soon attempts were made to insert metal rods or inject radio-opaque substances to give clear pictures of organs and vessels, with mixed results. The first angiography, moving-picture X-rays, and military radiology were performed in early 1896.”(6) Imagine little mini space crafts flying all around the moon one year after the first step? These advancements are so prolific that the discovery of the X-ray is almost always referred to as: “a momentous event that instantly revolutionized the fields of physics and medicine”(1)

In the early 1900’s “some experimentalists began applying the rays to treating disease”(7) These experiments eventually led to the treatment of cancer, which will be discussed in the next section. Though the medical society at this point has plenty to learn, like the impacts of X-ray radiation and the profound ability it has to decrease the growth of cancerous cells, its advances are impressive and promising. 

Modern Medicine

  1. X-ray. (2018). NHS. https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/x-ray/

How is the X-ray used? This source discusses the modern uses of the rays, what they can be used to diagnose and how they work (which was covered in section one) Today the X-ray is prized, used in almost every hospital in the US and the UK on a daily basis. This is because, without the cumberance of surgery, doctors can take an accurate look at the skeletal system, and currently: the digestive, cardiovascular, and respiratory system. Surgery is no longer a form of diagnosis, instead it is a form of treatment. This leaves less room for flaws like death on the operating table (which happened more frequently in the 1800’s then now) and this ‘new’ technology gives doctors some breathing room. 

NHS gives some examples of common users of the X-ray: “X-rays are usually carried out in hospital X-ray departments by trained specialists called radiographers, although they can also be done by other healthcare professionals, such as dentists”(3) Specialists are required to operate the X-ray machine in order to protect the patient from harmful side effects like radiation (which will be covered in section three). Before the structure on operating the X-ray, common folk with no medical degrees would attempt to use the X-ray for profit or amusement in the late 1800’s. Old shoe companies would use the X-ray saying it was a “scientific approach to shoe fitting” until, in 1949, “the American Standards Association had issued a safety code for industrial use of X-rays, limiting exposure to 0.1 R per day” (https://spectrum.ieee.org)

Now that such knowledge of the dangers of the X-ray are in place, Doctors can feel free to go along with diagnosing “bone fractures and breaks tooth problems, such as loose teeth and dental abscesses, scoliosis (abnormal curvature of the spine), non-cancerous and cancerous bone tumours, lung problems, such as pneumonia and lung cancer, dysphagia (swallowing problems), heart problems, such as heart failure, breast cancer”(8) All of these uses of the X-ray have a modern day significance, the X-ray aiding doctors in saving lives and also making medical procedures easier and more predictable. 

  1. Chodos, A., & Ouellette, J. (2001, November). Roentgen’s discovery of x-rays. APS News, Volume 10. https://www.aps.org/publications/apsnews/200111/history.cfm

How does the X-ray correlate with the treatment of Cancer in a positive way? Professor Rontgen himself never attempted treating cancer with the Rontgen rays, though his successors did. And their discoveries afterward seemed just as significant. Electrotherapy, invented by Luigi Galvani, was placed in Juxtaposition to the X-ray in January 1896. Both of which were claimed to relieve pain, of mental or physical origins. An electrotherapist by the name of “Emil Grubbe irradiated a woman with a recurrent cancer of the breast, and by the end of the year, several researchers had noted the palliative effects of the rays on cancers”(7)

  1. (July, 2019) NIH (National Cancer Institution) Radiation Therapy for Cancer. https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/treatment/types/radiation-therapy

Radiotherapy, as it has come to be called, is an expected form of killing cancerous cells, depending on how treatable the tumor is. Radiation damages DNA, it enters DNA strands or water molecules in the body and it changes the original code, mutating the genetic information and removing some or all of the cancer. The unwanted cells are killed over a time period of weeks or months because the radiation levels have to be controlled and minimal. There are two types of Radiotherapy, as an article from NIH states: “External beam radiation therapy comes from a machine that aims radiation at your cancer. The machine is large and may be noisy. It does not touch you, but can move around you, sending radiation to a part of your body from many directions.”(4) The other type of radiation therapy is much more discreet, “Internal radiation therapy is a treatment in which a source of radiation is put inside your body. The radiation source can be solid or liquid.”(6) Internal radiation is placed in one’s body through a capsule like a pill, placed near the intrusion of the cancerous cells, giving off radiation for a selected period of time. Killing the cells of the tumor.

There are different ways to treat or threaten different cancers: “Brachytherapy is most often used to treat cancers of the head and neck, breast, cervix, prostate, and eye”(13) and “A systemic radiation therapy called radioactive iodine, or I-131, is most often used to treat certain types of thyroid cancer”(14) The X-ray machine is a device that produces radiation. This device has been altered into a different machine with the same concepts yet different functions. The LINAC device is the most common form of external beam-therapy radiation and is used to help “treat cancers of the brain, spine, head and neck, lung, breast, esophagus, stomach, rectum, uterus, prostate, bladder, liver and bones.”(16) All the external technology for treating cancers is a result of Roentgen’s discovery and his followers, scientist who walked through his footsteps and beyond with their own discoveries and experiments. 

Radiation and its Effects

  1. **Raman, C. V., F.R.S. (1928). A new radiation*. http://repository.ias.ac.in/70648/     1/36-PUb.pdf

This is a primary source research paper of a physicist from India who focused on light-scattering. C V Raman spoke about his experiments and conclusions in his lecture to the South Indian Science Association on Friday, 16th, March, 1928 at Bangalore. A mixture of thermodynamics and fluorescent-screen experiments take place in this paper, yet only the importance of radiation and the X-ray will be referred to. 

It is recognized that the X-ray and this “new radiation” can be compared: *“It is thus clear that each line in the incident spectrum gives rise to at least two lines in the scattered spectrum, one in the original or unmodified position and a second in a shifted position of a longer wavelength. There is thus a striking analogy with the Compton effect in the X-ray region”(373) The X-ray is compared to this new radiation which can be seen through a spectroscope similar to a cathode which is used for the visualization of X-rays. Therefore, the X-ray does produce radiation because it has similar effects on the stethoscope as a study that focuses solely on a form of radiation rather than a ray. 

Radiation is not portrayed on earth as it is in movies or the media. As Raman states in his lecture: *“The remarkable observation was made that the visible radiation]….[is strongly polarized”(370) This means that the likelihood of radiation spreading so vastly that a buck grows a second head(The 100, 2014) or a woman turns into a tree(Annihilation, 2018) are incredibly slim chances. The true witnessed effects of radiation are much more minimal, but in a way, equally as threatening. 

  1. How Does Radiation Affect Humans? (1994). ACHRE.   https://bioethicsarchive.georgetown.edu/achre/final/intro_9_5.html

This source is an isolated part of an educational paper with many sections, including what DNA is, and how radiation can affect human DNA. The specific process of radiation that causes genetic mutation is “ionization radiation”. Ionization is the process in which molecules gain negative or positive charge by gaining or losing electrons to provoke change. An analogy that can be used to explain this process is water and liquid paint. Say a glass of water is a group of DNA molecules in a human body, these DNA molecules hold the code and genetic make up of a person. If red paint is poured into a section of the cup, the water is changed and is now undrinkable. The cup of water no longer serves the human body the way it was meant to, now that the product is “damaged” by an outside source. If radiation affects DNA molecules or water molecules in the human body then those “codes” are damaged and the product of the code is rewritten to create “side effects” that can result in mutation of the body’s genetic make up. 

Radiation is an electromagnetic wave that has the ability to move through matter. According to the paper presented by ACHRE: “Altering chemical bonds may change composition or structure. Ionizing radiation is powerful enough to do this. For example, a typical ionization releases six to seven times the energy needed to break the chemical bond between two carbon atoms. This ability to disrupt chemical bonds means that ionizing radiation focuses its impact in a very small but crucial area”(2) This is evidence that radiation is extremely polarized, focusing itself in one molecule at a time. To receive radiotherapy treatment for a brain tumor, the specialists place a special cap over the patient’s head, with holes where the radiation should go. This is not to prevent the radiation from “spreading” to other areas of the brain, it is to prevent the original source of radiation from covering the entire head. Once radiation has been introduced to a subject, it cannot “infect” further subjects. Radiation is not contagious among the molecules in a body, it stays put and damages the cells it has been introduced to. 

There are certain side effects of radiation, the mutation of genes is the most cumbersome. When radiation toxifies a DNA molecule it becomes hereditary. That specific mutated gene will sometimes be passed down to the creature’s spawns, like any blue-eyed parent having a blue-eyed kid. This makes radiation poisoning a life sentence for the children of certain victims. “It takes much longer for the biological effects to become apparent. If the damage is sufficient to kill the cell, the effect may become noticeable in hours or days”(6) A great amount of cell death can result in the death of the carrier of the radiation within “twenty-four hours”. Death is the most obvious result of some ionization radiation poisoning, though it’s not the most prominent effect. Typically a patient is not exposed to that vast amount of radiation. 

Sometimes radiation does not kill the cell, but instead “alter its DNA code in a way that leaves the cell alive but with an error in the DNA blueprint. The effect of this mutation will depend on the nature of the error and when it is read. Since this is a random process, such effects are now called stochastic”(7) According to the archive there are two types of cell mutation, one type of mutation leads to the infamous cancerous cells, which, in the polarized area, results in the growth of a tumor from the infected cells. The other type of radiation mutation was discussed above, labeled: “heritable changes, which result from mutations in germ cells (eggs and sperm).” This spreads the effects of radiation down the generations bloodline. 

Because cancer was discussed above, genetic mutations will be covered in this last paragraph. In this next quote is a description (in a neat package) of what hereditary mutation by ionization radiation is:  “mutations that occur in germ cells (sperm and ova) can be transmitted to future generations and are therefore called genetic or heritable effects. Genetic effects may not appear until many generations later]…[Genetic mutation due to radiation does not produce the visible monstrosities of science fiction; it simply produces a greater frequency of the same mutations that occur continuously and spontaneously in nature”(10) these hereditary mutations can take over a thousand forms, from metabolic disorders to liver cancers. It truly depends “linearly on dose and that there is no threshold below which mutation rates would not be increased.”(13) This means that the amount of radiation a patient has been exposed to predicts the side effects that follow. 

The X-Ray in America

  1. **Cleveland Moffett (1896, March, 28). THE RONTGEN RAYS IN AMERICA. Gutenburg. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/14663/14663-h/14663-h.htm#page403

Soon after the discovery of the X-ray, in 1896, the Rontgen rays had become a worldwide phenomenon, reaching and influencing American scientists as well as inventors, professors and the common public. One of those inventors is known as extremely prolific in his creations and discoveries, recognized now as revolutionizing the lightbulb, telephone, telegraph and he worked on the X-ray soon after its discovery, Thomas Alva Edison.  The author of this source, Cleveland Moffett, is mentioned in an 1896 print newspaper archived here:

As a primary source he visited professors like Arthur W. Wright, who experimented with the cathode rays. Moffet also discussed X-rays with Dr. William J. Morton of New York, who was the first man to demonstrate effects of the X-ray without the Crookes tube, which was a big deal because the Crookes tube was expensive and Dr. Morton’s way would allow “students who, being unable to provide themselves with the rare and expensive Crookes tubes, may buy a radiometer which would serve their purpose excellently in any laboratory supply store, the cost being only a few dollars.”(p. 24)

Along with Mr. Wright and Dr. Morton, Cleveland discusses: “Thomas A. Edison” who “has also been devoting himself, with his usual energy, to experiments with the Rontgen rays, and announces confidently that in the near future he will be able to photograph the human brain, through the heavy bones of the skull, and perhaps even to get a shadow picture showing the [entire] human skeleton through the tissues of the body” (p. 27) 

  1. Hancox, J. (2021). Thomas Edison. Radiology. https://radiopaedia.org/articles/     thomas-edison?lang=us

Thomas Edison was experimenting with the reaction of fluorescence and fluorescent tubes with the X-ray. He and his team, including valued laboratory assistant: Clarence Dalley, were working “obsessively” to develop new discoveries with the X-ray, so it is no surprise “a hand organ player was employed to keep the team awake”(3), albeit, slightly humorous. After publishing a device called the fluoroscope to “Scientific American in 1896”(1) and experimenting with the rays day and night, Edison quit. After his assistance death (Clarence Dalley), Thomas said:  ‘”don’t talk to me about x-rays, I am afraid of them.”’(5), for Clarence Dalley had died of a skin cancer, which can only correlate with his deep involvement with the radiation from the X-ray experiments. Whether this correlation was the cause of the cancer, it is unknown. Despite this tragic setback, the fluoroscopy, invented by Thomas Edison, is still used in hospitals in America, today.

Leave a Reply