SOURCES:
A review of Edward Taylor’s theories:
Hopi Agriculture:
And a short film Hopi Songs of the Fourth World by Pat Ferrero (1985).
A Provisional Definition of Religion:
Elements of religion that do not explain religion as a whole and are subject to change;
- Non-physical/non-observable ways people explain or guide their lives and experiences (can be spiritual, conceptual, or otherwise)
- A belief system for people to have faith in during troubling times when physical solutions cannot be implemented.
Two Limitations in this Definition:
I don’t think that religion as a whole can fit into one definition because there are so many aspects of it. “Religion” is hard to define for some of the same reasons “art” is hard to define. These words require cultural context, and they encompass so many different mediums/outlets. In this way, I agree with the text that religion can’t be completely defined by one single definition. Another limitation in my definition is I tried to define religion by the two main ways people use it, but these are not all the purposes or elements of religion, and that’s a huge crater in my definition. In an attempt not to copy the example, I tried approaching the prompt from a different angle, but if the example wasn’t there, I probably would have come up with something very similar to it.
What Taylor’s theories miss, distort, or fail to account for in Hopi life:
When I was watching the video on Edward Taylor, I noticed he seemed to think scientific reasoning was “superior” to ideas from a religion. I thought this was odd because “science” and the “scientific method” is just another belief system. Science is just another religion. One of the main steps in the scientific method is observation, but because not everything in life can be observed, science is not a fully “factual” way of explaining life as we cannot possibly know and observe everything in the universe. Because of this, the scientific community generally agrees that science cannot prove anything beyond a doubt.
So early anthropologists like Taylor, and likely modern anthropologists as well, were blinded by their assumption that science was a superior or “higher cognition” way of thinking, when fundamentally, it’s not too different from other religions. It’s just another way of explaining our experiences. Because of this blindness, Taylor ignored the value in acknowledging spirits and inanimate entities; something science is incapable of because of its insistence on observation.
If I wrote why acknowledging spirits is so important and why science’s reliance on observation is a huge downside when it comes to practicality, I’d have to write at least five more paragraphs. I’m reluctant to summarize, but the assignment did, say, “briefly explain.” Theories like Taylor’s ignore the value of belief in things that cannot be physically observed. For example, the Hopi believing that corn has a soul has led to much better care and consideration of the crops and environment. These results would have likely been overlooked by anthropologists who were blinded by the “primitive” (their words, not mine) nature of this belief.
Editing Note: I don’t feel that I’m explaining this very well. When I say “the value of acknowledging spirits” I am not saying that spirits and souls exist. I am saying that humans tend to treat things better when we believe there’s a “soul” or “spirit” attached to it. Racism, animal cruelty, and environmental neglect tend to go hand-in-hand with believing certain things don’t have “personhood.”
Disclaimer: No part of this writing is meant to be taken as fact or as a professional academic review. These are simply my thoughts and have little research or expertise behind them.


