Media Control: What Are YOU To Do About It? (A Brief Overview)

Cover image is curtesy of this absolute masterpiece:

Ok, onto the blog post…

(ALSO FYI: Apparently there are ads I can’t remove here. Please ignore them. Whatever it is, you don’t need it).

In the video above, Democracy Now discusses Stephen Colbert’s show being canceled after he publicly criticized the Trump administration.

This is a clear example of media censorship with a “hidden”, although pretty obvious, political agenda. As David Sirota states, Trump’s censorship agenda “conflicts with the whole notion of America First” and free speech. This example illustrates just how bad media censorship is getting, as it’s starting to infringe on citizens ability to express their political views without endangering their career.

I personally believe strongly in free speech and that it’s not okay “to pick and choose” what’s “acceptable” as free speech as long as that speech is not a threat or somehow directly endangering someone’s life.

Many authoritarian countries make it illegal to publicly criticize the authority of said country. The more we infringe on the people’s right to criticize their government, the closer we get to an authoritarian government and farther from a Democratic Republic. And frankly, I don’t think we can even call ourselves that anymore. 

John Oliver in this video explains how the Sinclair Broadcasting News Company owns and controls the scripts for local news stations.

He explains how it’s not always obvious when a local news story is being pushed/written by the Sinclair Broadcasting Group. Sometimes locals are unaware that these stories posted across multiple city stations are not actually coming from the city itself. What this means is a corporate agenda is being spread through “local” news stations, which are, according to a study he presented, more trusted than corporate news channels.

Media ownership is not always obvious or straightforward. It’s important to do your research on your local news stations and know where the stories are coming from. 

WHAT DID I LEARN?

First off, I didn’t realize the Republican news could be so utterly hilarious when watching it purely for comedic value. The bits Oliver presented on Mark Hyman made me laugh out loud (literally) for the first time in a while, and not because I agree with him, purely because of the blunt absurdity of his statements.

Secondly, I’m not surprised, but I didn’t realize how “in-the-open” media corporations were about their unethical business practices. CBS banning someone for sharing their political opinion and Sinclair Broadcasting Group sharing the exact same story across local channels without bothering to rewrite them even a little bit.

Having the “must release” rule also seems unethical. It’s forcing a company that works under them to promote a story or belief that they don’t agree with.

It’s like if my retail boss says, “you must tell every customer that comes through your line to vote for so and so”. Someone working in a political campaign might, of course, expect to be promoting a political agenda, but a local news channel working for a corporation? Although not surprising, it doesn’t seem very proffesional.

How do you apprehend the control of media over the messages and ideas that inform the citizens of a representative democracy? (Class question:)

I would not refer to our country as a representative democracy, because a large majority of policies are influenced more by corporations than our elected government officials. Our current method of government (as it is, not as it’s presented) is not technically a democracy.

Democracy def; “a system of government by the whole population or all the eligible members of a state, typically through elected representatives.”

Because our governmental systems are so heavily influenced/run by corporations and the wealthy, it’s no longer a government “for the people, by the people.” A quick look at the homeless outside, or the rapists who get let out on “supervised release” just to go back home and abuse their wives/girlfriend/daughter/etc. make it abundantly obvious these systems are not “for the people.”

So, correction: This plutocratic oligarchy IS NOT a democracy; It’s just made to look like one.

The majority of U.S. presidents are of a higher social class than the majority of U.S. citizens. They do not represent us. The system is set up to favor the rich, with political campaigns being funded by corporations/CEO’s which the president then feels indebted to if they win.

As much as I disagree with how current media companies control the messages they distribute, I also can’t fault them.

If I owned a media company, I too would want to control the messages and stories to promote my own agenda. I think it’s difficult to find the balance between unethically spreading false information and someone having control over what their company represents.

I think the best solution is what we’re doing now: Educating U.S. citizens about media control because a surprising number of people believe things said on the news and even believe everything they learn in school!

With that said, trust no one and believe nothing (not even anything I’ve stated in this blog post:) 

What independent sources of media — news and entertainment — might you find to balance the diet of ideas that you’re ingesting every day? (Class question 2)

I honestly never watch the news and the closest my Instagram feed gets to political is the Nazi-Hitler jokes (it’s okay, guys, my granddad is Jewish) as my feed is mostly artists, cats and baking recipes.

If you are going to watch the news, and even if you’re not, I think the best media to consume to “balance your diet” is local musical artists or art of any kind.

I don’t watch the news because if the apocalypse is happening, I want to enjoy the last seconds before the end. I don’t want to know about it ’cause that might make it hard to enjoy my morning coffee (assuming, of course, the apocalypse starts after 10:00am.

You might argue, well don’t you care about others? Wouldn’t you want to know if your fellow man is suffering so you can help? To that I say, if you want to help humanity, then you really shouldn’t watch the news. It’ll only discourage you. Join a volunteer group, bake stuff for the homeless people in your area, study biochemical warfare and destroy humanity to give the planet a fresh start.

If you want to help, watching the news will likely just drain your resolve.

3 Replies to “Media Control: What Are YOU To Do About It? (A Brief Overview)”

  1. Hi, I like your analysis! I agree that our system of government has definitely been leaning away from democracy; like you said, corporations have way more power and influence than they should. I respectfully disagree with you about not watching the news; I do agree with you that news can be very discouraging and will only leave you feeling burnt-out, but I do think it’s still important to stay informed and find multiple sources of news so you can pick out the facts and try to separate the bias. Consuming art as well as volunteering and the other examples you mentioned are definitely good ideas, though.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Hi!

    I really like your mention of how we don’t really live in a democracy anymore, due to corporations influence on our government and news. I also appreciated your acknowledgement that if you owned a news company you would also run your beliefs. I think that’s important to consider because we will never truly have unbiased news, even those claiming to be are bias against the other bias news outlets. I also agree that often watching the news just makes people depressed, and doesn’t actually help us help others, instead it makes people spiral. I would add that for people that feel watching the news it truly important or have it as a big part of their morning routine, getting news from small, independently owned news outlets (if you live in Humboldt, Lost Coast Outpost is one) is the best bet for news that is truly focused on spreading awareness about what’s important in our community.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. You make good (sad) feisty argument about our country not being a representative democracy. This: “This plutocratic oligarchy IS NOT a democracy; It’s just made to look like one.”

    Yes, ugh.

    Also you make a fair point about the news. I have to watch because 1) I teach journalism and 2) I feel like I need to be informed so I can try to fight a good fight for our once and future democracy. 😉

    Thanks for your post!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply